OpenFrontiers
← Back to the index
OP-8533Status unassessedGeometry and topology

The deep-fall property and the Atiyah Conjecture

L2L^2 invariants and their relatives for finitely generated groups · Historical workshop question

Editorial mapping of AIMPL source category: Geometric group theory. http://aimpl.org/l2invariantsgroups/ Not an author-supplied MSC code.

Historical list · status unassessedAs of 2026-09-08Source & evidence ↓
Some source formulas need transcription review

The imported text contains notation that could not be rendered reliably. Check the original source before using the affected formulas. The source text is retained below for inspection.

Find many examples of left-orderable groups and their free actions on complexes that have the deep-fall property in some dimension $i$. Find free actions by left orderable groups that do not have the deep-fall property.  See what can be said about non-free actions on ordered complexes. The same will formally apply to matrices with entries in the group ring over $\mathbb{C}$.

## Workshop introduction

This problem list concerns the study of the asymptotic behavior of some natural invariants of finitely generated groups.

## Question context

This notion was used in the paper ``Sumultiplicativity and the Hanna Neumann Conjecture". 
Let $\hat{Y}$ be a complex with a free action by a left-orderable group~$\Gamma$ and $i\ge 0$.
This induces a $\Gamma$-invariant total order on the set of $i$-cells in $\hat{Y}$, $\Sigma_i^{\hat{Y}}$.
For  $\sigma\in \Sigma_i^{\hat{Y}}$ and $E\subseteq \Sigma_i^{\hat{Y}}\setminus \{\sigma\}$,
let 
$$
[E<\sigma] := \{ \tau\in E |\tau<\sigma \} .
$$
We say that $\sigma$ {\em falls into} $E$ if 
$\partial\sigma\in \overline{\partial(\ell^2(E))}$.
A cell $\sigma\in \Sigma_i^{\hat{Y}}$ is called {\bf order-essential} if it falls into 
$[\Sigma^{\hat{Y}}_i< \sigma]$, i.e. 
$$\partial\sigma\in 
\overline{\partial(\ell^2[\Sigma^{\hat{Y}}_i< \sigma])}.$$ Call it {\bf order-inessential} otherwise.
Let $\mathbb{E}^{\hat{Y}}_i$ and $\mathbb{I}^{\hat{Y}}_i$ denote the sets of order-essential and order-inessential edges in $\hat{Y}$, respectively. 
We say that the $\Gamma$-action on $\hat{Y}$ has the {\bf deep-fall property}, or more precisely  $i$-deep-fall property, if for any 
$\sigma\in \mathbb{E}^{\hat{Y}}_i$ we have $\partial\sigma\in 
\overline{\partial(\ell^2[\mathbb{I}^{\hat{Y}}_i< \sigma])}$.

The argument in ``Sumbmultiplicativity ..." implies that each free action of a left-orderable group $\Gamma$ on a complex with the deep-fall property for some $i$ provides an instance when the (integral) Atiyah Conjecture holds. (Represent the $i$th boundary map by a matrix with entries in $\mathbb{Z}\Gamma$ and see that the kernel has integral dimension.) So for future investigation we propose

Historical workshop record. Current open/solved status has not been independently reassessed.

The source supplies no status note for this question.

Problem statement

Find many examples of left-orderable groups and their free actions on complexes that have the deep-fall property in some dimension ii. Find free actions by left orderable groups that do not have the deep-fall property. See what can be said about non-free actions on ordered complexes. The same will formally apply to matrices with entries in the group ring over C\mathbb{C}.

Lean 4

Not yet attached

No Lean statement or proof is attached yet. Have a formalization? Share its source to add it to this problem.

Background

Workshop introduction

This problem list concerns the study of the asymptotic behavior of some natural invariants of finitely generated groups.

Question context

This notion was used in the paper ``Sumultiplicativity and the Hanna Neumann Conjecture". Let Y^\hat{Y} be a complex with a free action by a left-orderable group~Γ\Gamma and i≥0i\ge 0. This induces a Γ\Gamma-invariant total order on the set of ii-cells in Y^\hat{Y}, ΣiY^\Sigma_i^{\hat{Y}}. For σ∈ΣiY^\sigma\in \Sigma_i^{\hat{Y}} and E⊆ΣiY^∖{σ}E\subseteq \Sigma_i^{\hat{Y}}\setminus \{\sigma\}, let

[E<σ]:={τ∈E∣τ<σ}.[E<\sigma] := \{ \tau\in E |\tau<\sigma \} .

We say that σ\sigma {\em falls into} EE if ∂σ∈∂(ℓ2(E))‾\partial\sigma\in \overline{\partial(\ell^2(E))}. A cell σ∈ΣiY^\sigma\in \Sigma_i^{\hat{Y}} is called {\bf order-essential} if it falls into [ΣiY^<σ][\Sigma^{\hat{Y}}_i< \sigma], i.e.

\overline{\partial(\ell^2[\Sigma^{\hat{Y}}_i< \sigma])}.$$ Call it {\bf order-inessential} otherwise. Let $\mathbb{E}^{\hat{Y}}_i$ and $\mathbb{I}^{\hat{Y}}_i$ denote the sets of order-essential and order-inessential edges in $\hat{Y}$, respectively. We say that the $\Gamma$-action on $\hat{Y}$ has the {\bf deep-fall property}, or more precisely $i$-deep-fall property, if for any $\sigma\in \mathbb{E}^{\hat{Y}}_i$ we have $\partial\sigma\in \overline{\partial(\ell^2[\mathbb{I}^{\hat{Y}}_i< \sigma])}$. The argument in ``Sumbmultiplicativity ..." implies that each free action of a left-orderable group $\Gamma$ on a complex with the deep-fall property for some $i$ provides an instance when the (integral) Atiyah Conjecture holds. (Represent the $i$th boundary map by a matrix with entries in $\mathbb{Z}\Gamma$ and see that the kernel has integral dimension.) So for future investigation we propose

Progress & source assessment

Historical workshop record. Current open/solved status has not been independently reassessed.

The source supplies no status note for this question.

References
  1. [1]$L^2$ invariants and their relatives for finitely generated groups link

Recorded progress

Add yours →

Nothing recorded yet. A pointer to a paper the entry is missing counts.

Machine attempts

0 recorded

Attempts run against the statement below and are recorded in full, including the failures. The point is to stop the next model — and the next person — from re-walking a road that is already known to end. Each attempt costs 25 credits.

No machine attempts recorded.

Sign in to run an attempt. New accounts start with enough credits for ten.

Discussion

0 notes

Notes are for clarifying the statement, flagging a missing reference, or recording why an approach fails. Claimed solutions belong in a submission, where they can be reviewed.

No notes yet.

Sign in to add a note.